In the face of impending storms, protecting our homes becomes a top priority. And when it comes to safeguarding against the wrath of hurricanes, the age-old debate arises: are impact windows as strong as hurricane shutters? While both options offer a level of protection, the strength and durability of impact windows have proven to be a game-changer. embedded with a special layer of impact-resistant glass, these windows not only provide protection from hurricanes but also offer a myriad of additional benefits, making them an increasingly popular choice for homeowners in hurricane-prone areas. Let’s unravel the truth behind the strength of impact windows and why they might just be the ultimate shield against nature’s fury.
What are impact windows and hurricane shutters?
Definition of impact windows
Impact windows, also known as hurricane windows or storm windows, are specially designed windows that are constructed to withstand the high winds and impact forces caused by hurricanes and other severe weather events. They are made using laminated glass, which consists of two panes of glass bonded together with a layer of strong, shatter-resistant plastic in between. This construction allows impact windows to absorb the impact of flying debris and prevent it from entering the home or causing damage.
Definition of hurricane shutters
Hurricane shutters are sturdy, protective coverings that are installed over windows and doors to shield them from the destructive forces of hurricanes and severe storms. They come in various forms, including metal panels, accordion-style shutters, roll-down shutters, and colonial shutters. Hurricane shutters are designed to be strong and impact-resistant, providing a physical barrier against flying debris and high winds.
Material and Construction
Impact windows
Impact windows are constructed using laminated glass, which is a combination of glass and polyvinyl butyral (PVB) or ethylene-vinyl acetate (EVA) interlayer. This interlayer is what gives the glass its strength and ability to withstand impact forces. The glass is also reinforced with a durable frame made from materials such as aluminum or vinyl, ensuring the overall structural integrity of the window.
Hurricane shutters
Hurricane shutters are typically made from strong and durable materials such as aluminum, steel, or polycarbonate. These materials are designed to be impact-resistant and can effectively withstand high winds and flying debris. The shutters are also equipped with a secure locking system to keep them firmly in place during a storm.
This image is property of www.homerunfinancing.com.
Resistance against High Wind Speeds
Impact windows
Impact windows are engineered to withstand high wind speeds, making them a reliable choice for areas prone to hurricanes and tropical storms. The laminated glass used in impact windows is specifically tested and rated to withstand wind speeds of up to 200 miles per hour or more. Additionally, the reinforced frames and proper installation ensure that the windows stay securely in place, even during extreme wind conditions.
Hurricane shutters
Hurricane shutters are also designed to resist high wind speeds. The specific resistance depends on the type of shutter chosen. Metal panels, for example, are typically rated to withstand wind speeds of up to 150 miles per hour, while stronger options such as roll-down shutters can withstand wind speeds of up to 200 miles per hour or more. Proper installation and maintenance of the shutters are essential to ensure their effectiveness in withstanding high wind speeds.
Protection against Debris
Impact windows
One of the primary functions of impact windows is to provide protection against flying debris during a hurricane or severe storm. The laminated glass used in impact windows is designed to stay intact even when struck by debris. While the glass may crack upon impact, the interlayer holds it together, preventing shards of glass from entering the home. This not only protects the occupants but also helps to maintain the structural integrity of the building.
Hurricane shutters
Hurricane shutters are also effective in protecting against flying debris. The robust construction and impact-resistant materials used in the shutters prevent objects from breaking through and entering the home. Whether it’s metal panels, accordion-style shutters, roll-down shutters, or colonial shutters, they all serve as a physical barrier to keep debris from damaging windows and doors.
This image is property of egsinternationalllc.com.
Durability and Longevity
Impact windows
Impact windows are designed to be highly durable and long-lasting. The laminated glass used in their construction is resistant to cracking and shattering, ensuring that the windows can withstand repeated impacts. Additionally, the frames of impact windows are typically made from materials that are resistant to corrosion, rot, and other forms of damage, extending the overall lifespan of the windows.
Hurricane shutters
Hurricane shutters are also built to be durable and resilient. The materials used, such as aluminum or steel, offer excellent strength and resistance to damage. Proper maintenance and regular inspections can help prolong the lifespan of hurricane shutters, ensuring their effectiveness over many years.
Installation Process
Impact windows
The installation of impact windows generally involves a professional installation team. The process begins with the removal of the existing windows and the preparation of the window opening. The impact windows are then carefully placed and secured into the opening using screws or other fasteners. Proper sealing and weatherproofing measures are taken to ensure the windows are installed correctly and provide maximum protection.
Hurricane shutters
The installation process for hurricane shutters varies depending on the type of shutters chosen. Metal panels require attaching them to the window frames using brackets, while accordion-style shutters are mounted on tracks alongside the windows. Roll-down shutters are typically installed above the windows and can be operated manually or electrically. Colonial shutters are hinged and swing closed to cover the windows. Professional installation is recommended for hurricane shutters to ensure correct placement and proper operation.
This image is property of www.homerunfinancing.com.
Maintenance Requirements
Impact windows
The maintenance requirements for impact windows are relatively low. Regular cleaning of the glass and frames with mild soap and water is usually sufficient to keep them in good condition. Inspections should be conducted periodically to check for any damage or cracks in the glass. The weatherstripping and seals should also be inspected and replaced if necessary.
Hurricane shutters
The maintenance requirements for hurricane shutters depend on the type of shutters installed. Metal panels may require occasional cleaning and inspection for signs of rust or corrosion. Accordion-style shutters should be lubricated regularly to ensure smooth operation. Roll-down shutters and colonial shutters should be inspected for any wear and tear, with particular attention paid to the motor or mechanical components. Any necessary repairs or replacements should be carried out promptly to maintain the functionality of the shutters.
Energy Efficiency
Impact windows
Impact windows are known for their energy-efficient properties. The laminated glass used in their construction provides an additional layer of insulation, reducing heat transfer and improving the overall energy efficiency of the home. This can result in lower energy bills and increased comfort by keeping the home cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter.
Hurricane shutters
Hurricane shutters, while effective in providing storm protection, do not offer the same level of energy efficiency as impact windows. As they are typically mounted outside the window, they do not provide the same insulation benefits. However, the added protection they provide during severe weather events can help prevent damage to the windows, which can contribute to energy loss in the long run.
This image is property of destinglass.com.
Aesthetic Appeal
Impact windows
Impact windows are available in a wide range of styles, sizes, and designs, allowing homeowners to choose options that complement their home’s architecture and personal aesthetic preferences. They can seamlessly blend in with the existing design elements, offering an attractive appearance both from the inside and outside of the home. Additionally, the clarity of the laminated glass in impact windows allows for ample natural light to enter the space, creating a bright and inviting atmosphere.
Hurricane shutters
The aesthetic appeal of hurricane shutters can vary depending on the type chosen. Metal panels, while offering robust protection, may not be visually appealing to some homeowners. Accordion-style shutters, roll-down shutters, and colonial shutters, on the other hand, can add a decorative touch to the exterior of the home. These shutters are available in various colors and styles, allowing homeowners to enhance the overall curb appeal of their property.
Cost Comparison
Impact windows
Impact windows tend to be more expensive upfront compared to hurricane shutters. The cost of impact windows can vary depending on factors such as size, style, brand, and installation requirements. However, their long-term benefits, including energy efficiency and increased property value, often outweigh the initial investment.
Hurricane shutters
Hurricane shutters generally have a lower upfront cost compared to impact windows. The cost varies depending on the type of shutters chosen, the size of the windows, and any additional features or customization. While hurricane shutters may require periodic maintenance and eventual replacement, they offer a cost-effective solution for storm protection.
In conclusion, both impact windows and hurricane shutters serve as effective means of protecting homes against the destructive forces of hurricanes and severe weather events. Impact windows offer the advantage of enhanced energy efficiency, durability, and aesthetic appeal, while hurricane shutters provide a cost-effective solution with flexibility in terms of design and style. Ultimately, the decision between impact windows and hurricane shutters depends on factors such as budget, personal preferences, and the specific needs of the home. Consulting with a professional can help homeowners make an informed choice based on their unique circumstances.
This image is property of eliteimpactglass.com.