In this article, we will be discussing the effectiveness of hurricane windows compared to hurricane shutters. We will explore the advantages and disadvantages of both options, as well as their cost and maintenance requirements. By the end of this article, you will have a clear understanding of whether hurricane windows or hurricane shutters are the better choice for protecting your home during a storm.
This image is property of eurexshutters.com.
When it comes to protecting our homes from hurricane-force winds and flying debris, we have two main options: hurricane windows and hurricane shutters. Both of these solutions are designed to keep our homes safe during severe weather conditions. In this article, we will compare the advantages and disadvantages of hurricane windows and hurricane shutters, as well as their effectiveness in protecting against high winds and flying debris. We will also discuss cost considerations, aesthetics, maintenance, and ease of installation and use.
Understanding Hurricane Windows
What are hurricane windows?
Hurricane windows, also known as impact windows, are specially designed to withstand the powerful forces generated by hurricanes and severe storms. These windows are made with a strong, impact-resistant glass that is capable of withstanding high winds and flying debris. Unlike regular windows, hurricane windows are made with multiple layers of glass and are often reinforced with a layer of laminated glass or a clear polymer interlayer.
How do hurricane windows work?
The key to the effectiveness of hurricane windows lies in their construction. The multiple layers of glass, along with the laminated or interlayer material, help to absorb the impact of flying debris and prevent the glass from shattering. Additionally, hurricane windows are securely attached to the window frame, often with a reinforced frame or anchoring system, to ensure that they stay in place during a storm.
Types of hurricane windows
There are several types of hurricane windows available in the market today. Some of the most common types include:
- Single-hung hurricane windows: These windows have a fixed upper sash and a bottom sash that can be opened and closed.
- Double-hung hurricane windows: Similar to single-hung windows, but both the upper and lower sashes can be opened and closed.
- Casement hurricane windows: These windows are hinged on one side and open outward with the help of a crank mechanism.
- Sliding hurricane windows: Also known as gliding windows, these windows have one or more sashes that slide horizontally.
Understanding Hurricane Shutters
What are hurricane shutters?
Hurricane shutters are protective coverings that can be installed over windows and doors to shield them from the damaging effects of hurricanes and severe storms. These shutters are typically made from durable materials such as aluminum, steel, or polycarbonate, and are designed to withstand strong winds and flying debris.
How do hurricane shutters work?
The primary function of hurricane shutters is to create a physical barrier between the windows or doors and the outside environment. When a hurricane or severe storm is approaching, the shutters can be closed to protect the glass from being shattered by high winds or flying debris. Depending on the type of shutters, they can be manually operated or motorized for easy use.
Types of hurricane shutters
There are several types of hurricane shutters available, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. Some of the most common types include:
- Accordion hurricane shutters: These shutters are made from interlocking slats that fold together accordion-style when closed.
- Roll-up hurricane shutters: These shutters roll up into a compact box when not in use and can be easily deployed when needed.
- Bahama hurricane shutters: These shutters are hinged at the top and can be propped open at an angle to provide shade and ventilation when not in use.
- Storm panel hurricane shutters: These shutters are made from either metal or polycarbonate panels that are installed over the windows when a storm is approaching.
Comparing Hurricane Windows and Hurricane Shutters
Effectiveness in protecting against high winds
Both hurricane windows and hurricane shutters are effective in protecting against high winds. Hurricane windows are designed to withstand wind speeds of up to 200 mph, while hurricane shutters can provide protection against even stronger winds. However, it is important to note that the effectiveness of both solutions may depend on the specific design and installation.
Effectiveness in protecting against flying debris
When it comes to protecting against flying debris, hurricane windows have a clear advantage. The laminated or interlayer material used in the construction of hurricane windows is specifically designed to prevent the glass from shattering when hit by flying objects. Hurricane shutters can also provide protection against flying debris, but the strength and durability of the chosen material will determine their effectiveness.
Cost is an important factor to consider when choosing between hurricane windows and hurricane shutters. Hurricane windows tend to be more expensive upfront compared to hurricane shutters. The cost of hurricane windows will vary depending on factors such as the size of the window, the type of glass used, and any additional features or enhancements. On the other hand, hurricane shutters are available at a range of price points, depending on the type and material chosen.
Aesthetics and maintenance
In terms of aesthetics, hurricane windows are considered more visually appealing. They blend seamlessly with the existing design of the home and do not require any additional coverings or shutters. Hurricane shutters, on the other hand, can add a distinct look to the home, but some homeowners may find them less aesthetically pleasing. In terms of maintenance, both hurricane windows and shutters require regular cleaning and inspection to ensure proper functionality.
Ease of installation and use
The installation process for hurricane windows and hurricane shutters can vary. Hurricane windows typically require professional installation due to their complex construction and precise fitting. On the other hand, hurricane shutters can be installed by homeowners themselves, especially if they choose a type that is designed for DIY installation. In terms of ease of use, hurricane shutters can be operated manually or remotely with the help of a motor, while hurricane windows function like regular windows and can be opened and closed as needed.
This image is property of hurricaneshutterpros.com.
Advantages of Hurricane Windows
Increased energy efficiency
One of the main advantages of hurricane windows is their energy efficiency. The multiple layers of glass and the laminated or interlayer material used in their construction provide enhanced insulation, reducing heat transfer and improving the overall energy efficiency of the home. This can lead to lower energy bills and increased comfort.
Hurricane windows offer an added layer of security to our homes. The impact-resistant glass and reinforced frames make it difficult for intruders to break in. Additionally, some hurricane windows come with additional security features such as laminated glass with a hardened interlayer that provides protection against forced entry.
Reduced noise pollution
Another benefit of hurricane windows is their ability to reduce noise pollution. The multiple layers of glass and the additional interlayer material help to block out unwanted noise from outside, creating a quieter and more peaceful indoor environment.
Increased property value
Investing in hurricane windows can significantly increase the value of our property. Potential buyers may see the added protection and energy efficiency provided by hurricane windows as desirable features, making our home more attractive to the market.
Advantages of Hurricane Shutters
One of the advantages of hurricane shutters is their greater customizability. Depending on the type and material chosen, hurricane shutters can be customized to match the style and design of our home. This allows us to maintain the aesthetic integrity of our property while still enjoying the benefits of storm protection.
Potential cost savings
While hurricane windows may have a higher upfront cost, hurricane shutters can provide potential cost savings in the long run. Shutters can help to reduce our homeowner’s insurance premiums, as they are considered a protective feature that mitigates the risk of hurricane damage. By installing hurricane shutters, we may be eligible for insurance discounts.
Hurricane shutters can also offer an additional level of privacy. When the shutters are closed, they create a barrier that blocks the view into our home. This can be particularly beneficial for those living in densely populated areas or near busy streets.
This image is property of egsinternationalllc.com.
Disadvantages of Hurricane Windows
Higher upfront cost
One of the main disadvantages of hurricane windows is their higher upfront cost compared to hurricane shutters. The cost of purchasing and installing hurricane windows can vary depending on factors such as the size of the windows and the specific requirements of our property. This higher cost may deter some homeowners from choosing hurricane windows as their storm protection solution.
Potential damage to the glass
While hurricane windows are designed to withstand the impact of flying debris, there is still a risk of damage to the glass. In the event that the glass does get damaged, it will require replacement to maintain the effectiveness of the windows. This can be an additional expense and inconvenience.
Disadvantages of Hurricane Shutters
Hurricane shutters require regular maintenance to ensure that they are in good working condition. This includes inspecting the shutters for any signs of wear or damage, lubricating the hinges and tracks, and cleaning the shutters regularly. Failure to properly maintain the shutters can lead to reduced effectiveness and potential damage during a storm.
Limited design options
While hurricane shutters offer greater customizability in terms of design, there are still some limitations compared to hurricane windows. The various types of hurricane shutters have their own aesthetic characteristics, and some homeowners may find it challenging to find a style that matches their preferences or the existing design of their home.
This image is property of destinglass.com.
In conclusion, both hurricane windows and hurricane shutters are effective solutions for protecting our homes from the damaging effects of hurricanes and severe storms. Hurricane windows offer increased energy efficiency, enhanced security, reduced noise pollution, and increased property value. On the other hand, hurricane shutters provide greater customizability, potential cost savings, and additional privacy. It is important to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of each solution and choose the one that best suits our needs and preferences. Ultimately, the decision between hurricane windows and hurricane shutters comes down to personal preference, budget, and the specific requirements of our property.