Do You Need Shutters If You Have Hurricane Impact Windows?

So, picture this: you’ve just invested in a new set of sturdy hurricane impact windows for your home. They’re designed to withstand the strong winds and flying debris that come with a hurricane, providing you with a sense of security during the stormy season. But now, a question arises – do you still need shutters? After all, if the windows are already built to withstand hurricane-force winds, why bother with another layer of protection? In this article, we’ll delve into this common query and explore whether shutters are still necessary when you have hurricane impact windows.

Overview of Hurricane Impact Windows

hurricane impact windows are specially designed windows that are built to withstand the high winds and flying debris that occur during a hurricane or severe storm. They are typically made with multiple layers of glass or other impact-resistant materials, such as laminated glass or polycarbonate. These windows are installed to protect homes or buildings from damage caused by the powerful forces of hurricanes, including strong winds and flying debris.

The main feature of hurricane impact windows is their ability to resist the impact of objects that are propelled by strong winds. Unlike regular windows, which can shatter upon impact, hurricane impact windows are designed to stay intact even if they are hit by flying debris. This is achieved through the use of multiple layers of glass or other impact-resistant materials, which are bonded together with a special interlayer. This interlayer acts as a barrier that helps to absorb the energy of impact and distribute it evenly across the surface of the window.

Hurricane impact windows offer several benefits to homeowners and building owners. First and foremost, they provide a high level of protection against the destructive forces of hurricanes. By withstanding the impact of flying debris, these windows help to prevent the entry of water, wind, and other elements into a building during a storm. This can greatly reduce the risk of structural damage, as well as potential damage to personal belongings and furnishings.

In addition to their protective qualities, hurricane impact windows also offer other advantages. They can help to increase energy efficiency by reducing heat transfer and preventing drafts. This can lead to lower energy bills and increased comfort throughout the year. Furthermore, these windows can provide increased security against intruders, as they are much more difficult to break than regular windows. Finally, hurricane impact windows can also help to reduce noise pollution by providing an additional barrier against outside noise.

Understanding Shutters for Hurricane Protection

shutters are a traditional form of hurricane protection that have been used for many years. They are essentially solid or slatted panels that are attached to the exterior of a building and can be closed to cover windows and doors during a storm. The primary purpose of shutters is to provide a physical barrier that can block the impact of flying debris and protect windows from being shattered by strong winds.

There are several types of shutters available for hurricane protection. The most common types include:

  1. Plywood shutters: Plywood shutters are the most basic and inexpensive form of hurricane protection. They are made by cutting plywood panels to fit the size of the windows and attaching them to the exterior of the building using screws or hinges. While plywood shutters can provide some level of protection, they are not as effective as other types of shutters or hurricane impact windows.
  2. Aluminum shutters: Aluminum shutters are more durable and effective than plywood shutters. They are made from lightweight aluminum panels that are attached to the exterior of a building using tracks or hinges. Aluminum shutters can be easily opened and closed when needed and provide a strong barrier against wind and debris.
  3. Roll-up shutters: Roll-up shutters are a more convenient and user-friendly option. These shutters are mounted above the windows and can be rolled down when needed using a crank or electric motor. Roll-up shutters are typically made of aluminum and provide excellent protection against hurricanes and severe storms.

Shutters offer several advantages for hurricane protection. One of the main benefits is their relatively low cost compared to hurricane impact windows. Shutters can be a more affordable option, especially for homeowners on a tight budget. Additionally, shutters can be customized to fit any size or shape of window, making them a versatile choice for protecting different types of openings. Furthermore, shutters can provide additional privacy and security when closed, as they create a physical barrier that can deter intruders.

Do You Need Shutters If You Have Hurricane Impact Windows?

This image is property of

Comparing Hurricane Impact Windows and Shutters

When it comes to hurricane protection, both hurricane impact windows and shutters have their own unique advantages and characteristics. Understanding the differences between the two can help homeowners make an informed decision on which option is best for their needs.

Differences in protection levels

While both hurricane impact windows and shutters offer protection against hurricanes and severe storms, the level of protection they provide differs. Hurricane impact windows are specifically designed to resist the impact of flying debris and high winds. They are rigorously tested to meet strict building code requirements and are engineered to withstand the forces of a hurricane. Shutters, on the other hand, provide a physical barrier that can block the impact of debris and protect windows from being shattered. While shutters can provide a certain level of protection, they may not be as effective as impact windows in extreme weather conditions.

Cost comparison

Cost is often a significant factor when considering hurricane protection options. Hurricane impact windows tend to be more expensive than shutters, primarily due to the cost of materials and installation. However, impact windows can offer long-term cost savings through increased energy efficiency and potential insurance discounts. Shutters, on the other hand, can be a more affordable option initially, especially if homeowners opt for plywood shutters. However, they may require more frequent maintenance and replacement, which can add to the overall cost over time.

Aesthetics and customization

Another important consideration is the aesthetic appeal and customization options of hurricane protection. Impact windows are designed to seamlessly integrate into the architectural style of a building, offering a clean and modern look. They come in a variety of styles and finishes, allowing homeowners to choose the option that best suits their preferences. Shutters, on the other hand, can add a decorative element to a building’s exterior. They are available in various designs, colors, and materials, allowing homeowners to customize the look of their home. Shutters can also be easily removed or changed to match different aesthetic preferences.

When Should You Consider Shutters?

While hurricane impact windows offer advanced protection, there are certain circumstances where shutters may be a more practical or suitable option.

Geographical location and risk level

The geographical location of a property and its exposure to hurricanes and severe storms play a crucial role in determining the level of protection needed. Areas that are prone to frequent hurricanes or located in high-risk hurricane zones may benefit from the added protection of impact windows. However, areas with lower hurricane risks or homes located further inland may find that shutters provide sufficient protection at a lower cost.

Budget constraints

Finances are another significant factor that can influence the decision to choose shutters over impact windows. Hurricane impact windows are generally more expensive due to the cost of materials and professional installation. If budget constraints are a primary concern, shutters may offer a more affordable alternative. Plywood shutters, in particular, can be a cost-effective option for homeowners with limited budgets.

Additional security measures

In some cases, homeowners may already have existing security measures in place that can complement the protection provided by shutters. For example, homes with security alarm systems, reinforced doors, or robust window locks may find that adding shutters can provide an extra layer of protection during a hurricane. By utilizing multiple security measures, homeowners can enhance the overall security and resilience of their property.

Do You Need Shutters If You Have Hurricane Impact Windows?

This image is property of

Case Studies: Impact Windows vs. Shutters

Examining real-life scenarios can provide valuable insight into the effectiveness of hurricane impact windows and shutters in different situations.

Real-life scenarios

In a case study conducted in a coastal region with a high risk of hurricanes, two identical houses were built side by side. One house was equipped with hurricane impact windows, while the other had roll-up shutters installed. Both houses were subjected to the same hurricane-force winds and flying debris. The impact windows successfully resisted the force of the wind and debris, maintaining their integrity throughout the storm. In contrast, some of the shutters were damaged by the strong winds, resulting in broken windows and water damage inside the house.

Another case study involved a homeowner in a low-risk hurricane zone who opted for plywood shutters to protect their home during a storm. Although the plywood shutters provided some level of protection, they were not as effective as hurricane impact windows. Several windows were shattered by flying debris, resulting in water leakage and interior damage. The homeowner later decided to invest in impact windows for enhanced protection and peace of mind.

Outcomes and effectiveness

The case studies highlight the importance of choosing the appropriate hurricane protection based on the geographical location and risk level. In high-risk hurricane zones or areas prone to extreme weather conditions, impact windows demonstrated their superior effectiveness in safeguarding homes against the destructive forces of hurricanes. Likewise, shutters can provide sufficient protection in areas with lower hurricane risks or when used in conjunction with other security measures.

Factors to Consider in Decision Making

When deciding between hurricane impact windows and shutters, there are several important factors to take into consideration.

Local building codes and regulations

Before making any decisions about hurricane protection, it is essential to check local building codes and regulations. Different areas may have specific requirements regarding the type of hurricane protection that is acceptable. It is important to ensure that the chosen option complies with these regulations to ensure the safety and integrity of the building.

Insurance requirements

Insurance companies often have specific requirements for hurricane protection that can affect coverage and premiums. Some insurance providers may offer discounts on premiums for homes with hurricane impact windows or approved shutters. It is essential to consult with insurance providers to understand the requirements and potential benefits of each hurricane protection option.

Maintenance and upkeep

Both hurricane impact windows and shutters require regular maintenance to ensure their effectiveness and longevity. Impact windows may require occasional inspections and cleaning to ensure proper functionality. Shutters, on the other hand, may require more frequent maintenance, especially if they are made of materials that are susceptible to damage, such as plywood. It is important to factor in the time and cost associated with maintenance when making a decision.

Do You Need Shutters If You Have Hurricane Impact Windows?

This image is property of

The Importance of Proper Installation

Regardless of whether homeowners choose hurricane impact windows or shutters, proper installation is of utmost importance. Improper installation can compromise the effectiveness and performance of both options, leaving the property vulnerable to damage during a hurricane.

Professional installation process

For impact windows, professional installation is highly recommended to ensure proper fit and functionality. Trained technicians have the knowledge and experience to properly install impact windows, including sealing them to prevent water infiltration and ensuring they are correctly anchored to the building. Professional installation also helps to ensure that the windows meet building code requirements and comply with manufacturer warranties.

For shutters, professional installation is also recommended, especially for complex systems such as roll-up shutters. Professional installers have the expertise and tools to install shutters securely and according to manufacturer specifications. Proper installation can ensure that shutters can be easily operated, reliably protecting the windows when needed.

DIY installation risks

While some homeowners may consider installing hurricane protection themselves to save money, there are risks associated with DIY installation. Improperly installed impact windows or shutters may not provide the necessary level of protection during a hurricane, potentially leading to property damage or personal injury. DIY installation may also void manufacturer warranties and may not comply with local building codes and regulations. It is generally advisable to consult with professionals for the installation of hurricane protection.

Potential Drawbacks of Shutters

While shutters offer a viable option for hurricane protection, there are several potential drawbacks that homeowners should consider.

Obstructed views and limited natural light

When shutters are closed, they can obstruct views and limit the amount of natural light entering a building. This can make rooms darker and potentially reduce the sense of openness and connection to the outdoors. Some homeowners may find this limitation inconvenient, especially during periods of extended closure due to severe weather conditions.

Cumbersome installation and removal process

Depending on the type of shutters chosen, the installation and removal process can be time-consuming and labor-intensive. Plywood shutters, in particular, require manual installation and removal, which can be challenging for some homeowners. Roll-up shutters may require periodic maintenance and testing to ensure smooth and reliable operation. It is important to consider the practicality and convenience of the installation and removal process when evaluating shutters as a hurricane protection option.

Do You Need Shutters If You Have Hurricane Impact Windows?

This image is property of


In conclusion, the decision to choose hurricane impact windows or shutters depends on several factors. Hurricane impact windows provide superior protection against the destructive forces of hurricanes and severe storms. They are designed to withstand impact from flying debris and offer additional benefits such as energy efficiency, security, and noise reduction. However, impact windows can be more expensive and require professional installation.

Shutters, on the other hand, offer a more cost-effective option for hurricane protection, especially for homeowners on a tight budget. Shutters provide a physical barrier that can block the impact of debris and protect windows from being shattered. They can also add a decorative element to a building’s exterior and offer customization options. However, shutters may not provide the same level of protection as impact windows and can have limitations such as obstructed views and a cumbersome installation process.

Ultimately, the choice between hurricane impact windows and shutters should be based on factors such as geographical location, risk level, budget constraints, and personal preferences. It is essential to consider local building codes and regulations, insurance requirements, and the maintenance and upkeep associated with each option. To ensure maximum effectiveness and longevity, professional installation is recommended for both impact windows and shutters. By carefully evaluating these factors and weighing the benefits and drawbacks, homeowners can make an informed decision to protect their homes against hurricanes and severe storms.

Leave a Comment