Do You Still Need Hurricane Shutters With Impact Windows?

Well, that’s a question we often get asked. Impact windows have become increasingly popular in areas prone to hurricanes, and for good reason. These windows are designed to withstand the impact of flying debris and are highly effective in protecting homes from strong winds. However, the question remains: do you still need hurricane shutters with impact windows? In our upcoming article, we will delve into this topic and provide you with all the necessary information to make an informed decision. So stay tuned!

If you’re wondering whether investing in hurricane shutters is still necessary when you already have impact windows installed, we’ve got you covered. We understand that the safety and security of your home are of utmost importance to you, especially during hurricane season. In our upcoming article, we will explore the benefits and limitations of impact windows and hurricane shutters, allowing you to weigh your options. So, keep an eye out for our next piece, where we will provide expert insights and advice on this matter.

Do You Still Need Hurricane Shutters With Impact Windows?

This image is property of

Understanding Hurricane Shutters and Impact Windows

When it comes to protecting your home from the devastating effects of hurricanes, two popular options are hurricane shutters and impact windows. Both of these solutions offer added security and peace of mind during extreme weather conditions. However, there are some key differences between the two that homeowners should consider before making a decision. In this article, we will explore the purpose and benefits of hurricane shutters, the effectiveness of impact windows, and when it might be necessary to use both together.

The Purpose of Hurricane Shutters

The primary purpose of hurricane shutters is to safeguard your home and its occupants during severe storms. These shutters are specifically designed to withstand high winds and flying debris that can result from hurricane-force winds. They act as a barrier that protects your windows and doors, preventing them from shattering and causing further damage to your home’s interior.

The Benefits of Impact Windows

Impact windows, on the other hand, offer a more permanent solution to hurricane protection. These specially designed windows are made with multiple layers of glass that are bonded together with a strong interlayer. This construction allows the windows to withstand both high winds and the impact of flying debris, making them an effective barrier against hurricane damage.

In addition to their hurricane-resistant properties, impact windows also offer other notable benefits. They can help reduce outside noise, increase energy efficiency by reducing heat transfer, and provide added security against burglars and intruders. These features make impact windows a popular choice for homeowners seeking long-term protection and investment.

Differences between Hurricane Shutters and Impact Windows

While both hurricane shutters and impact windows offer protection during hurricanes, there are some key differences to consider. Hurricane shutters are typically less expensive than impact windows, making them a more affordable option for homeowners on a budget. Additionally, they provide additional protection during a storm by covering windows and doors completely, shielding them from potential damage.

On the other hand, impact windows offer continuous protection year-round without the need for any additional measures. They are a permanent fixture on your home, enhancing its aesthetic appeal and increasing its value. Impact windows also provide greater insulation, helping to keep your home comfortable and energy-efficient.

Effectiveness of Impact Windows

How Impact Windows Protect Against Hurricanes

To understand the effectiveness of impact windows, it’s important to know how they protect against hurricanes. These windows are designed and tested to withstand strong winds and the impact of flying debris. They are made with laminated glass, which consists of two or more panes bonded together with a strong interlayer. This interlayer holds the glass together even if it cracks upon impact, preventing it from shattering and causing further damage.

Additionally, impact windows have a reinforced frame that adds strength and stability. This frame is specially engineered to withstand the increased pressure and force exerted by hurricane winds. With their durable construction, impact windows provide an effective barrier against hurricane damage, protecting your home and its occupants.

Testing and Certification of Impact Windows

Before being marketed as impact windows, these products undergo rigorous testing to ensure their effectiveness. In the United States, the most widely recognized testing protocol for impact windows is the Miami-Dade County product approval process. Under this process, impact windows are subjected to rigorous testing, including wind resistance tests, projectile impact tests, and water penetration tests.

If impact windows meet the stringent requirements set by Miami-Dade County, they receive the coveted “Miami-Dade County Product Control Approved” certification. This certification verifies that the windows have demonstrated their ability to withstand hurricane-force winds and flying debris. Homeowners should look for this certification when selecting impact windows to ensure the highest level of protection.

Limitations of Impact Windows

While impact windows are highly effective at protecting homes from hurricanes, it’s important to note their limitations. While they can withstand the impact of flying debris and high winds, they may not be able to prevent water intrusion if there are breaches in other areas of your home’s exterior. It’s crucial to ensure that your home’s roofing, doors, and other openings are also properly secured to prevent water damage during a hurricane.

Additionally, impact windows can be a significant investment. The cost of installing impact windows throughout your home can be higher compared to hurricane shutters. Homeowners should carefully consider their budget and priorities when choosing between impact windows and shutters.

Advantages of Hurricane Shutters

Additional Protection During Hurricanes

One of the primary advantages of hurricane shutters is that they offer an extra layer of protection to your windows and doors during hurricanes. They can withstand the impact of flying debris and create a barrier that prevents projectiles from breaking through the glass. This added protection can be crucial in areas prone to frequent hurricanes or intense storms.

Versatility and Affordability of Shutter Options

Another advantage of hurricane shutters is their versatility and affordability. There are a variety of shutter options available to suit different tastes and budgets. Some popular types of hurricane shutters include accordion shutters, roll-down shutters, Bahama shutters, colonial shutters, and storm panels. Each type has its own unique features and benefits, allowing homeowners to choose the best option for their needs.

Hurricane shutters are generally more affordable compared to impact windows. This cost-effectiveness can be appealing to homeowners who want reliable storm protection without the higher investment of impact windows.

Greater Ease of Installation and Maintenance

Hurricane shutters are relatively easy to install and maintain. Depending on the type of shutter, they can be manually operated or motorized for added convenience. Some shutters can be permanently affixed to your home, while others can be stored away when not in use. The ease of installation and maintenance can be particularly beneficial for homeowners who prefer a more hands-on approach or those who live in areas with a high frequency of hurricanes.

When to Consider the Use of Hurricane Shutters

Areas Prone to Extreme Weather Conditions

If you live in an area that is prone to frequent hurricanes or experiences extreme weather conditions, it is advisable to consider using hurricane shutters. These shutters provide an extra layer of protection and can significantly reduce the risk of window and door damage during storms. By investing in hurricane shutters, you can have peace of mind knowing that your home is well-prepared for any potential storms.

Budget Constraints and Prioritization of Protection

Another factor to consider when deciding whether to install hurricane shutters is your budget. Impact windows can be a significant investment, especially if you have multiple windows and doors in your home. If you have budget constraints, hurricane shutters can provide a more affordable solution while still offering effective storm protection.

Additionally, if you have other home improvement projects or priorities, such as roof repairs or retrofitting, it may be more feasible to allocate your budget towards those projects first. Hurricane shutters can be installed at a later time when you have additional funds available.

Desire for Added Security and Energy Efficiency

Hurricane shutters can also provide added security and energy efficiency benefits. When shutters are closed, they not only protect your home from hurricane damage but also create a barrier against potential break-ins. Some types of shutters, such as roll-down shutters, provide enhanced security features that make it difficult for intruders to gain access to your home.

Additionally, when hurricane shutters are closed, they can help reduce heat transfer, thereby increasing energy efficiency. By blocking out the sun’s heat and reducing the load on your air conditioning system, you can enjoy energy savings and a more comfortable living environment.

Do You Still Need Hurricane Shutters With Impact Windows?

This image is property of

Complementing Impact Windows with Hurricane Shutters

For homeowners seeking the highest level of storm protection, it may be worth considering the use of both impact windows and hurricane shutters. By combining these two solutions, you can enhance the overall protection of your home and create a multi-layered defense against hurricanes.

Enhancing Overall Storm Protection

While impact windows offer substantial protection on their own, adding hurricane shutters can provide an additional layer of defense. Shutters can act as the first line of defense during a storm, deflecting and dispersing the impact of flying debris. This reduces the strain on impact windows and further minimizes the risk of glass breakage.

Customizable Options and Aesthetic Appeal

Another advantage of using both impact windows and hurricane shutters together is the ability to customize the appearance of your home. Impact windows come in various styles and finishes, allowing you to choose the option that best suits your home’s architecture and your personal preferences. By complementing them with hurricane shutters, you can further enhance the aesthetic appeal of your home while ensuring its protection.

Retaining Structural Integrity During Severe Storms

Using both impact windows and hurricane shutters can help retain the structural integrity of your home during severe storms. In the event that an impact window does break due to extreme conditions, the hurricane shutter can act as a secondary barrier, preventing further damage and protecting your home from the elements.

Choosing the Right Type of Hurricane Shutters

When selecting hurricane shutters, it’s important to consider the different types available and choose the one that best suits your needs. Some popular options include:

Accordion Shutters

Accordion shutters are a popular choice due to their ease of use and affordability. These shutters are permanently affixed to the sides of windows or doors and can be easily unfolded and locked into place when needed. Accordion shutters are durable, providing reliable storm protection while also allowing natural light into your home when not in use.

Roll-Down Shutters

Roll-down shutters are another convenient option for homeowners seeking storm protection. These shutters are mounted above windows or doors and can be manually operated or motorized for added convenience. When closed, roll-down shutters create a sleek, clean look and provide excellent protection against hurricanes.

Bahama Shutters

Bahama shutters offer both protection and a unique architectural feature to your home. These shutters are hinged at the top and can be propped open to allow natural light and airflow. When a storm approaches, the shutters can be easily lowered and secured to protect your windows and doors.

Colonial Shutters

Colonial shutters are a classic and elegant choice for homeowners looking to add a touch of traditional charm to their homes. These shutters are installed on either side of windows and can be opened and closed manually. Colonial shutters not only offer storm protection but also add a decorative element to your home’s exterior.

Storm Panels

Storm panels are a cost-effective option for homeowners who want reliable storm protection without the permanent installation of shutters. These panels can be made of steel, aluminum, or polycarbonate and are easily installed when a storm is approaching. Storm panels provide excellent impact resistance and can be stored compactly when not in use.

When choosing the right type of hurricane shutters for your home, consider factors such as budget, style preferences, ease of use, and installation requirements. Consulting with a professional can help you make an informed decision that meets your specific needs.

Do You Still Need Hurricane Shutters With Impact Windows?

This image is property of

Installation and Maintenance of Hurricane Shutters

Professional Installation Versus DIY

The installation of hurricane shutters can vary depending on the type you choose. While some shutters can be installed as a DIY project, others may require professional installation. Accordion shutters and storm panels are often considered more DIY-friendly options, while roll-down shutters and Bahama shutters may require the assistance of trained professionals.

Professional installation ensures that your shutters are properly secured and function effectively during a storm. Additionally, professional installers can provide guidance on the best type of shutter for your home and ensure compliance with local building codes.

Proper Care and Maintenance for Longevity

To ensure the longevity and reliability of hurricane shutters, proper care and maintenance are essential. Regularly inspecting the shutters for any signs of damage or wear, such as loose screws or cracks, can help identify and address issues before they become more severe. Additionally, lubricating any moving parts and cleaning the shutters regularly can help extend their lifespan and maintain their functionality.

Preparing and Securing Shutters Before a Storm

When a storm is approaching, it’s important to properly prepare and secure your hurricane shutters. This involves closing and locking the shutters, ensuring that they are tightly sealed against your windows and doors. Any loose or damaged parts should be repaired or replaced before the storm hits.

Additionally, it’s advisable to have a plan in place for installing the shutters in a timely manner. By familiarizing yourself with the installation process and gathering the necessary tools and hardware ahead of time, you can ensure a smooth and efficient setup.

Factors to Consider Before Installing Impact Windows

While impact windows offer significant storm protection and other benefits, there are several factors to consider before making the investment.

Cost and Budget Allocation

The cost of impact windows can vary depending on factors such as the size of the window, the level of impact resistance, and the desired features. Generally, impact windows are more expensive compared to traditional windows and hurricane shutters. When considering impact windows, it’s important to evaluate your budget and allocate funds accordingly. Depending on your financial situation, it may be necessary to prioritize certain areas of your home for impact windows, such as the most vulnerable or high-risk areas.

Building Code Requirements

Another factor to consider when installing impact windows is compliance with local building codes. Different regions may have specific requirements for the type of impact windows that are allowed. It’s important to consult with local authorities or a professional installer to ensure that your impact windows meet the necessary codes and regulations.

Energy Efficiency Considerations

Impact windows offer excellent energy efficiency benefits, reducing heat transfer and increasing the insulation of your home. However, the level of energy efficiency can vary depending on factors such as the glass type, the number of panes, and the overall construction of the window. When selecting impact windows, consider their energy efficiency ratings and choose the option that best suits your climate and energy-saving goals.

Do You Still Need Hurricane Shutters With Impact Windows?

This image is property of

Balancing Cost and Benefits

Comparing the Costs of Impact Windows and Shutters

When weighing the costs and benefits of impact windows and shutters, homeowners should consider their individual circumstances and priorities. Impact windows offer long-term protection, energy efficiency, and added security benefits, but they can come at a higher cost compared to hurricane shutters.

On the other hand, hurricane shutters provide more budget-friendly protection and can be a suitable option for homeowners on a tighter budget. Furthermore, shutters offer versatility in terms of style and ease of installation.

Evaluating the Long-Term Value and Return on Investment

To determine the long-term value and return on investment, homeowners should consider the potential savings on insurance premiums, energy costs, and potential damage repairs. While impact windows may require a higher upfront investment, the long-term benefits and potential savings can make them a worthwhile investment.

For homeowners planning to stay in their homes for a prolonged period, impact windows can provide peace of mind and potentially increase the resale value. It’s important to evaluate the long-term benefits and savings when making a decision.

Weighing the Benefits Against Potential Risks

Lastly, homeowners should weigh the benefits of impact windows and shutters against potential risks. While both solutions offer protection during hurricanes, no system is entirely foolproof. It’s important to assess the unique conditions and risks in your area. Factors such as the distance to the coastline, the terrain, and the frequency of severe storms should be considered when determining the level of protection needed.

Additionally, homeowners should be aware of any potential limitations of impact windows or hurricane shutters and take appropriate measures to mitigate them. For example, ensuring your home’s exterior is properly sealed and secured can minimize the risk of water intrusion.


In conclusion, the decision to install hurricane shutters with impact windows ultimately depends on your individual circumstances, budget, and priorities. While impact windows provide an excellent long-term storm protection solution with added benefits, hurricane shutters offer an affordable and versatile option that can complement impact windows.

By understanding the purpose and benefits of both hurricane shutters and impact windows, homeowners can make informed decisions for optimal storm protection. Consider factors such as the risk of extreme weather conditions in your area, budget constraints, desire for added security and energy efficiency, and the value of potential long-term savings.

Ultimately, the decision between hurricane shutters and impact windows is a personal one, and it’s important to choose the option that aligns with your needs and preferences. Whether you opt for impact windows, hurricane shutters, or a combination of both, investing in storm protection is essential in ensuring the safety and well-being of your home and its occupants. Stay safe and prepared!

Do You Still Need Hurricane Shutters With Impact Windows?

This image is property of

Leave a Comment